An injury insurance claim denied in the mail feels final. It isn’t. A denial is the insurance company’s position on your claim, not a court’s decision.

You have the right to appeal the insurance decision if your insurance claim is denied. You also have the right to pursue legal action against the at-fault driver under Maryland’s personal injury laws. Which route fits depends on the reason printed on the letter.

It can be beneficial to talk with a car accident lawyer in Baltimore about your legal rights. Acting out of frustration, without a plan, could cost you compensation you’re owed. Call (410) 837-2144 for a free case review.

Reasons the Car Insurance Company May Give for Denying Your Insurance Claim

The reasons a car insurance provider gives for denying an injury claim fall into two groups. Which group you’re in decides what you do next.

Coverage denials

A coverage denial says the policy doesn’t cover this loss. It usually reads one of these ways:

  • The insurance policy had lapsed
  • The insurance policy did not cover the driver or the vehicle
  • The policy did not cover the cause of the car crash
  • You failed to file a timely claim
  • You did not provide the required documentation and information to file the claim

Coverage denials are answered with paper: the declarations page, the claim forms, proof of when you reported the crash.

Fault denials

A fault denial says you caused the crash, or helped cause it. Those read:

  • The insured driver did not cause the accident
  • You were partially to blame for the cause of the accident
  • There is insufficient proof that the car accident caused your injuries

This group matters more here than almost anywhere else. A person who fails to use ordinary care for their own safety, and contributes to their own injury, is barred from all recovery.1

Our explainer on Maryland contributory negligence covers the rule. So an insurance company with even a thin fault argument has a reason to hold its position, and that’s one way insurance companies fight claims. Fault denials are answered with evidence, not paper.

Sometimes an insurance company has a valid reason. More often it’s looking for a way not to pay. A personal injury attorney investigates the crash and gathers the evidence that establishes fault.

Make the Insurance Company Explain the Denial

Get the basis of the denial in writing before you argue with anyone. Maryland law makes that the insurance company’s job, not a favor. It’s an unfair claim settlement practice to fail to provide a reasonable explanation of the basis for a denial promptly on request.2

The state’s claim-handling regulation adds clocks that measure how an insurance company handles claims generally: 15 working days to acknowledge a claim, to affirm or deny coverage once it holds properly completed claim forms, and to reply to written communications that call for a response. A company that misses them as a regular practice violates the regulation.3

Working days, not calendar days. The affirm-or-deny clock starts on properly completed forms, which is why your records matter as much as your argument. The regulation covers first-party and third-party claimants alike, so it reaches you either way.4

Maryland Car Insurance Requirements

Maryland’s minimum liability coverage for bodily injury is $30,000 per person. If more than one person was hurt, the minimum is $60,000 per accident. Drivers must also carry at least $15,000 for property damage.5

Insurance companies must also offer PIP (Personal Injury Protection), though it isn’t required and it can be waived in writing. Maryland PIP generally pays medical bills and lost wages regardless of who caused the crash. The minimum is $2,500. Limited exclusions apply, for example if you intentionally caused the crash, were in a vehicle you knew was stolen, or were committing a felony, and policies can limit PIP for motorcycles, mopeds and scooters.5

PIP also produces a denial you can avoid. The Maryland Insurance Administration says PIP coverage can be denied if you don’t file claims properly and on time. Ask your own insurance company for the PIP forms right after a crash. They will specify your deadline date.5

Maryland is an At-Fault State for Car Insurance Claims

PIP doesn’t cover everything a crash costs. Maryland is an at-fault state, so the injury claim goes to the insurance company for the driver who caused the wreck. Damages you might recover include:

  • Medical bills
  • Loss of income
  • Pain and suffering
  • Loss of enjoyment of life
  • Disabilities and impairments
  • Scarring and disfigurement

The damage to your car isn’t on that list on purpose. Property damage is a separate claim, and its value doesn’t transfer into your injury claim.

You still have to prove the other driver caused the wreck. Even when the insurance company agrees its driver was at fault, it may still deny the claim.

Where to Take a Maryland Denial

You have options beyond the adjuster who told you no. The Maryland Insurance Administration takes consumer complaints, and the volume suggests a disputed claim is ordinary. It received 12,162 formal complaints in fiscal year 2025, 7,180 of them in property and casualty.6

Its Rapid Response Program handled another 2,070 inquiries, mostly automobile, homeowners, and liability.6 Formal complaints have to be in writing and should carry copies of the pertinent documents. An investigator then contacts the insurance company.5 Allow 90 days for a decision.7

Be honest about the limits, though: some disputes may be governed by your policy’s terms and aren’t a problem the Administration can resolve.5

A second route has real teeth, and it’s available only on a first-party claim. A good-faith complaint under section 27-1001 forces the insurance company to hand over its claim file. It must file a written response with each document within 30 days of receiving notice from the MIA and mail you a copy.8

The Administration then has 90 days to decide. Silence past 90 days counts as a determination that the insurance company didn’t breach anything.8

In the Administration’s published report on these cases for fiscal year 2023, it reviewed 76 complaints on the merits. It found no breach of an obligation to pay or to act in good faith in any of them.9

What Happens if the Insurance Company Refuses to Pay an Insurance Claim?

Experienced injury lawyers often negotiate a fair settlement without filing anything. An attorney builds the case from the evidence, submits a demand package, and negotiates when the insurance company counters. If the answer is a low offer rather than a flat no, rejecting a settlement offer is a separate decision.

If the insurance company won’t negotiate in good faith, your attorney may advise you to file a lawsuit. You would file that lawsuit against the driver or other party responsible for the crash. The insurance company is not named.

That isn’t a drafting quirk. Maryland doesn’t permit a direct action against a liability insurance company to resolve a negligence claim against the person it insures.10 The statutory failure-to-act-in-good-faith action is narrower than most people expect too. It applies only to first-party claims under property and casualty or individual disability policies.11

A first-party claim is one you make on your own policy, like PIP or uninsured motorist coverage. A third-party claim is the one you make against the driver who hit you. The Administration has dismissed an injured person’s good-faith complaint against the at-fault driver’s insurance company for lack of jurisdiction.10 Our explainer covers bad faith insurance claims as a concept; whether a particular denial crosses that line is a question for a lawyer reading your file.

Time is Not on Your Side When Fighting an Insurance Company

The statute of limitations for most car accident claims is generally 3 years from the date of the crash.12 Negotiating with an insurance company, appealing a denial, or filing a complaint doesn’t pause the deadline for suing the at-fault driver. Plan as if the three years keeps running no matter what the insurer is doing.

Some deadlines close much sooner. A claim against a Maryland local government entity requires written notice within 1 year of the injury. A claim against the State requires a written claim to the Treasurer or a designee, also within 1 year.13

Talk to a lawyer as soon as an insurance company denies your claim. A lawyer needs time to investigate before filing, and waiting too long can cost you your right to sue the driver who caused your accident.

What to Do After a Denial

A denial letter starts the argument. Three things are worth doing now.

  1. Ask for the basis in writing. Request a reasonable explanation of the basis for the denial.2 Put it in writing, because the reply clock runs on written communications.3
  2. Pull your file together. The denial letter, the claim number and adjuster’s name, the police report, medical bills and records, proof of lost wages, photographs, and copies of every letter and email. A first-party good-faith complaint, the one you file on your own coverage, has to carry each document you sent the insurance company for proof of loss.14 The Administration has dismissed one that didn’t show what was submitted.9
  3. Watch the deadline. Three years sounds long until you’ve spent a year appealing.12

None of that takes a lawyer. What comes next usually does.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I appeal a denied insurance claim, and to whom?

Yes, and there are three places to go. Back to the insurance company in writing, with records that answer its stated reason. To the Maryland Insurance Administration, informally through Rapid Response or by written complaint.6 And separately to court, against the at-fault driver.

Does a denial mean I cannot sue the driver who hit me?

No. The insurance company’s decision is not a court’s decision, and it doesn’t settle whether the driver was negligent. Your claim is against the driver, and the lawsuit names the driver, not the insurance company.10 The three-year filing deadline keeps running through every appeal.12

Can I sue the insurance company for denying my claim?

Usually not the other driver’s insurance company. Maryland’s statutory failure-to-act-in-good-faith action applies only to first-party claims under property and casualty or individual disability policies.11 It reaches your own insurance company on your own coverage, and it generally requires a complaint to the Maryland Insurance Administration first.8

Contact the Baltimore Car Accident Law Firm of WGK Personal Injury Lawyers Today For Help

For more information, contact the Baltimore car accident law firm of WGK Personal Injury Lawyers to schedule a free initial consultation.

Answering a denial shouldn’t add another errand to a week already full of appointments. Most personal injury cases run by phone, and you can sign documents remotely.

Our attorneys handle Maryland car accident claims statewide. The first conversation is free, and you pay nothing unless we recover compensation for you. Call (410) 837-2144 to start a free case review.

This content is marketing material and is not legal advice. Every case is unique and laws change frequently. Please contact our office to speak with an attorney about your specific situation before making any legal decisions.

Sources

  1. Coleman v. Soccer Association of Columbia (2013), quoting Harrison v. Montgomery County Board of Education (1983). Restatement of the contributory negligence rule. https://www.mdcourts.gov/data/opinions/coa/2013/9a12.pdf
  2. Md. Code, Insurance § 27-303 (unfair claim settlement practices), current compilation, Maryland General Assembly statute text, retrieved 2026-09-12. The duty to provide promptly on request a reasonable explanation of the basis for a denial, and the prohibition on refusing to pay for an arbitrary or capricious reason. Regulatory standard enforced by the Maryland Insurance Administration; not a private cause of action. https://mgaleg.maryland.gov/2026rs/Statute_Web/gin/27-303.pdf
  3. COMAR 31.15.07.03 (Unfair Claim Settlement Practices), Maryland Insurance Administration, via the official Maryland regulations library, retrieved 2026-09-12. The 15-working-day acknowledgment, affirm-or-deny and written-reply provisions in section B, which apply when committed with such frequency as to indicate a general business practice; the “properly completed claim forms” condition; and the Regulation .04B and policy-time-limit carve-out. https://regs.maryland.gov/us/md/exec/comar/31.15.07.03
  4. COMAR 31.15.07.02 (Definitions), Maryland Insurance Administration, via the official Maryland regulations library, retrieved 2026-09-12. Definitions of claimant, first-party claimant and third-party claimant for the chapter covering payment of claims under property and casualty policies. https://regs.maryland.gov/us/md/exec/comar/31.15.07.02
  5. Maryland Insurance Administration, A Consumer Guide to Auto Insurance (MIA-A-1, 2024), retrieved 2026-09-12. Minimum coverage figures of $30,000 per person, $60,000 per accident and $15,000 property damage; PIP as no-fault reimbursement of reasonable and necessary medical expenses and lost wages; the statement that PIP can be denied if claims are not properly and timely filed; and the complaint process, including the caveat that some disputes are governed by the policy’s terms. https://insurance.maryland.gov/Consumer/Documents/publications/autoinsuranceguide.pdf
  6. Maryland Insurance Administration Annual Report, Fiscal Year 2025 (Insurance Article § 2-110(a)), published December 2025, retrieved 2026-09-12. Table 3, Summary of FY25 Complaints: 12,162 formal complaints, of which 7,180 in Property and Casualty; and 2,070 Rapid Response Program inquiries, primarily automobile, homeowners and liability. https://insurance.maryland.gov/Consumer/Appeals and Grievances Reports/Maryland-Insurance-Administration-Annual-Report-FY-2025.pdf
  7. Maryland Insurance Administration, File A Complaint, retrieved 2026-09-12. The instruction to allow 90 days for a decision on a consumer complaint. https://insurance.maryland.gov/Consumer/Pages/FileAComplaint.aspx
  8. Md. Code, Insurance § 27-1001 (administrative good-faith process), current compilation, Maryland General Assembly statute text, retrieved 2026-09-12. The insurer’s 30-day written response with each document from its claim file and the copy mailed to the insured, the Administration’s 90-day decision window, and the rule that failure to decide within 90 days counts as a determination of no breach. https://mgaleg.maryland.gov/2026rs/Statute_Web/gin/27-1001.pdf
  9. Maryland Insurance Administration, 2023 Report on Absence of Good Faith Cases Filed under § 27-1001 of the Maryland Insurance Article (MSAR #6587), covering FY2023, published December 2023, retrieved 2026-09-12. Of 87 complaints, 76 were reviewed on the merits with no breach found; of the four dismissed, one was dismissed for failing to provide the documentation a § 27-1001 complaint requires. Most recent edition located. https://insurance.maryland.gov/Consumer/Appeals and Grievances Reports/2023-Report-on-Absence-of-Good-Faith-Cases-Filed-under-27-1001.pdf
  10. Maryland Insurance Administration, Office of the Insurance Commissioner, Decision and Order, Case No. 27-1001-23-00033, retrieved 2026-09-12. Dismissal of an injured claimant’s good-faith complaint against a liability insurer for lack of jurisdiction, and the rule that Maryland does not permit a direct action against a liability insurer to resolve a negligence claim against its insured, citing Harford Mut. Ins. Co. v. Woodfin Equities Corp. (1997). https://insurance.maryland.gov/Documents/orders/27-1001-23-00033-progressiveinsurancecompany.pdf
  11. Md. Code, Cts. & Jud. Proc. § 3-1701(b) (failure to act in good faith), current compilation, Maryland General Assembly statute text, retrieved 2026-09-12. The subtitle applies only to first-party claims under property and casualty or individual disability policies issued, sold or delivered in Maryland. https://mgaleg.maryland.gov/2026rs/Statute_Web/gcj/3-1701.pdf
  12. Md. Code, Cts. & Jud. Proc. § 5-101 (statute of limitations), current compilation, Maryland General Assembly statute text, retrieved 2026-09-12. A civil action at law shall be filed within three years from the date it accrues unless another provision of the Code provides a different period. https://mgaleg.maryland.gov/2026rs/Statute_Web/gcj/5-101.pdf
  13. Md. Code, Cts. & Jud. Proc. § 5-304 (notice of claim against a local government) and Md. Code, State Gov’t § 12-106 (written claim to the State Treasurer), current compilation, Maryland General Assembly statute text, retrieved 2026-09-12. Each requires written notice within one year. https://mgaleg.maryland.gov/2026rs/Statute_Web/gcj/5-304.pdf and https://mgaleg.maryland.gov/2026rs/Statute_Web/gsg/12-106.pdf
  14. Maryland Insurance Administration, A Guide for Consumers Filing a § 27-1001 Civil Complaint, retrieved 2026-09-12. The four filing requirements, including that the complaint be accompanied by each document the insured submitted to the insurer in support of the claim or for proof of loss. https://insurance.maryland.gov/consumer/documents/27-1001guide.pdf